Welcome to our comprehensive review of the top memory foam mattresses on the market! In this breakdown, we'll go deep into the details of three leading contenders: Nectar, Sienna, and Saatva. With comfort, support, and durability at the forefront of our evaluation, we aim to provide you with all the information you need to make an informed decision on which mattress is best suited to your sleep preferences and lifestyle. Whether you're seeking pressure relief, motion isolation, or cooling properties, we've got you covered. Let's explore the features, benefits, and drawbacks of each mattress to help you find the perfect fit for your bedroom sanctuary.
Nectar Memory Foam Mattress
Nectar stands out as the premier choice for memory foam mattresses, offering an ideal blend of quality and affordability. This all-foam mattress impresses with its remarkable value, catering to a broad spectrum of sleep preferences and styles.
Throughout our two-month evaluation of the Nectar Memory Foam mattress, it proved to be a standout performer. Featuring a soft, quilted cover designed for optimal cooling, it boasts three layers of foam: memory foam, support foam, and a sturdy base layer. The memory foam provides subtle body contouring without overwhelming sinkage, making it an easy transition for those accustomed to traditional innerspring mattresses.
Our testing revealed consistent performance across various criteria. The mattress exhibited commendable edge support, allowing for full utilization of the sleep surface and confident seating on the perimeter. Additionally, minimal motion transfer makes it an excellent choice for couples and individuals sharing a bed. Even in warm climates, the Nectar maintained favourable temperature regulation, though individuals with heightened heat sensitivity may explore specialized cooling alternatives.
With a firmness rating of 6.5 out of 10, the Nectar caters to a wide array of sleep positions. While side sleepers benefit most from its contouring properties, it also accommodates back and stomach sleepers, albeit with some caution, especially for individuals weighing over 230 pounds. In such cases, a firmer mattress like the Siena may be a preferable option. Ultimately, Nectar's versatility and value make it a top contender in the realm of memory foam mattresses.
BUY IT IF
✅ You sleep on your side: The Nectar excels for side sleepers, providing exceptional cushioning for shoulders and hips.
✅ You share a bed: Enjoy undisturbed sleep with the Nectar's top-notch motion isolation, ideal for restless partners.
DON'T BUY IT IF
❌ You sleep on your stomach: Stomach sleepers may find the Nectar's medium feel insufficient for optimal spine support.
❌ You get hot in the night: While the Nectar offers decent temperature regulation, it lacks specialized cooling features for hot sleepers.
Sienna Memory Foam Mattress
The Siena Memory Foam mattress stands out as our top budget-friendly choice, delivering remarkable quality at an incredibly low price point. As a product of the same parent brand as the Nectar (#1), it boasts a comparable triple-layered internal structure and overall craftsmanship, yet comes with a significantly reduced price tag. Currently offered at a discounted rate, the queen size is available for just $399, making it an exceptional value proposition.
Featuring a firmer feel compared to the Nectar, the Siena lacks the pronounced body contouring typically associated with memory foam mattresses. This characteristic makes it particularly well-suited for stomach and back sleepers, who benefit from a supportive sleep surface to maintain proper spinal alignment. However, side sleepers may find other options more accommodating to their need for enhanced pressure relief around the shoulders and hips.
In our evaluation, we found the Siena to excel in edge support and motion isolation, making it an ideal choice for individuals sharing a bed who prefer minimal disturbance from restless partners. While it may not offer the advanced temperature regulation of pricier memory foam models, the Siena still effectively manages body heat buildup.
Backed by a 10-year warranty and a generous 180-night trial period, the Siena provides peace of mind despite its budget-friendly pricing. Its superior quality surpasses other options in the budget mattress category, making it an excellent choice for guest rooms or as the best mattress for college students. For those seeking a more economical solution, consider complementing an innerspring mattress with one of the best memory foam mattress toppers to achieve a similar body-hugging sensation.
BUY IT IF
✅ You're on a tight budget: The Siena mattress offers exceptional affordability, typically priced at just $399 for a queen size.
✅ You value edge support: With its firmness and excellent edge support, the Siena mattress excels in minimizing motion transfer.
DON'T BUY IT IF
❌ You like a memory foam hug: Due to its firmness, the Siena lacks the plush sink-in feeling characteristic of traditional memory foam mattresses.
❌ You sleep on your side: Side sleepers may find the Siena lacking in cushioning for hips and shoulders due to its firmness.
Saatva Loom & Leaf
The Saatva Loom & Leaf mattress, a premium offering from the luxury online brand Saatva, impressed us during our three-week testing period. It stands out as one of the best mattresses for alleviating back pain, with our lead reviewer experiencing significant relief from her back injury after sleeping on this bed. Featuring a zoned design, the Loom & Leaf mattress incorporates a gel-infused foam lumbar crown in its reinforced middle third, targeting pressure relief and enhancing circulation in the lower back. Meanwhile, the top and bottom thirds offer slightly softer support, contouring to the shoulders and knees for added comfort.
Available in two firmness options—relaxed firm and firm—the Loom & Leaf mattress caters to various sleep preferences, ensuring comfortable contouring regardless of your preferred sleep style. While the mattress boasts some cooling technology, we found that it tended to retain heat overnight, which may be a consideration for those who tend to sleep hot. However, its exceptional motion isolation makes it an ideal choice for couples, minimizing disturbances from a restless partner.
Though prices have seen an increase over the past year, the Loom & Leaf mattress remains a worthwhile investment, even with regular Saatva mattress sales and deals. While not as pricey as our luxury pick, the Tempur-Pedic at #5, it still offers excellent value for its premium quality. Additionally, Saatva provides enticing extras, including a generous 1-year trial and lifetime warranty.
Saatva's commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in their white glove delivery service, which includes delivery to your room of choice and optional removal of your existing mattress. Given the weight of the mattress—up to 116lbs—this convenience is greatly appreciated. Furthermore, the handcrafted construction ensures durability, with long-time customers attesting to its enduring comfort even after years of regular use.
BUY IT IF
✅ You suffer from back pain: The Loom & Leaf is one of the best mattresses for back pain, offering two firmness options to suit individual preferences.
✅ You want a quality mattress: The Loom & Leaf boasts exceptional build quality, providing a luxurious sleeping experience akin to that of a high-end hotel bed.
DON'T BUY IT IF
❌ You think you might want to return it: While Saatva offers a 365-night trial with the Loom & Leaf, note that a $99 return fee applies if you decide to return the mattress.
❌ You get hot in the night: Despite its cooling features, some users may find that the Loom & Leaf occasionally traps heat overnight.