Coop Sleep Goods Original Pillow
Rarely do we encounter a product as meticulously well crafted as the Coop Sleep Goods Original Pillow. Crafted from hypoallergenic shredded memory foam, this pillow offers adjustable fill, allowing you to tailor the loft to your exact sleep preferences. Coupled with features like a washable cover, 5-year warranty, and 100-night trial, it stands out as our top pick.
Upon unboxing, you're greeted with a vibrant yellow insert guiding you through the customization process, recommending adjustments based on your favoured sleeping position. While initially brimming with fill, the pillow includes an extra half-pound bag for those seeking additional support. Following the instructions to tailor the fill for back sleepers resulted in a deeply personalized experience, striking a perfect balance between support and plushness.
Though the Coop Original pillow may lean towards the firmer side and retain warmth for those accustomed to softer fills, the brand offers alternatives such as the Coop Eden pillow with gel-infused memory foam for cooler sleep and a plush feel reminiscent of down. Additionally, COOP recently introduced The Essence, an adjustable down-alternative design, expanding their range of options to cater to diverse preferences.
What we like ✅
Completely customizable with removable fill
Comes with additional fill if you prefer a firmer pillow
Comes with a washable encasement
Hypoallergenic
5-year warranty
100-night trial
What we don’t like ❌
Testers in previous reviews thought it arrived with a slightly funny smell
Not be the best choice if you don't like memory foam
On the firmer side
Casper Original (Side Sleepers)
A quality pillow aims to maintain proper alignment of your neck and spine, especially crucial for side sleepers who need adequate support to bridge the gap between their ear and the mattress. However, individual variations in shoulder size and height mean that the ideal pillow loft can differ significantly from person to person.
For side sleepers seeking customizable support, our top choice is the Coop pillow, also named the best overall pillow for side sleepers in our guide. However, if memory foam isn't your preference, the Casper Original Pillow is an excellent alternative.
Crafted from hypoallergenic down-alternative fill and featuring a percale cotton shell, the Casper pillow offers a hotel-like plushness. Its 2-inch gusset maintains loftiness, providing the necessary support for side sleepers while still offering a soft, sinking sensation.
Senior home editor Jaclyn Turner, a combo sleeper favoring back and side positions, has enjoyed the Casper Original Pillow for over a year, appreciating its consistent loft and plush support. Another side sleeper who tested the pillow found it remained cool throughout the night and retained its shape despite its softer fill. If you seek a blend of support and softness, the Casper Original Pillow is worth considering, though it may lack the customization options of other pillows.
What we like ✅
Soft and fluffy
2-inch gusset that provides support for side sleepers
Removable inner pillow
Machine washable
100-night trial period
What we don’t like ❌
Loft is not very adjustable
Not as supportive as memory foam
Saatva Latex Pillow (Back Sleepers)
Crafted with a supportive shredded latex core encased in a plush down alternative layer and a sateen cotton liner, the Saatva Pillow boasts a one-of-a-kind design that sets it apart from any other pillow I've encountered. It combines the substantial weight and support akin to a memory foam pillow with the luxurious, cool sensation characteristic of a down pillow.
Available in two loft options, the standard loft measuring approximately 4-5 inches is recommended for back and stomach sleepers, while the high loft of 6-7 inches caters to side sleepers and those seeking added plushness.
Throughout my testing period, I found myself consistently drawn to this pillow, eventually making it my preferred choice for nights when I wasn't actively trying out new products.
Having slept on this pillow for five months now, I've grown to appreciate how my head sinks into its soft surface while still maintaining ample support to retain its shape throughout the night. Upon waking up, the pillow appears just as plush as it did when I first laid my head on it.
As someone who tends to move around frequently in bed and adjust my bedding accordingly, I've found the pillow to be equally comfortable and plush from all sides and angles. It remains soft and supportive even when folded, scooped, or hugged throughout the night, quickly rebounding to its original shape. Additionally, its hypoallergenic properties make it an ideal choice for allergy sufferers like myself.
However, some stomach sleepers who participated in our testing found the pillow to be overly lofty, even after removing the inner core. Similarly, certain side sleepers may find the pillow lacking in loftiness. Overall, we believe it is best suited for back sleepers and individuals who prefer a plush, cool feel over traditional memory foam pillows.
What we like ✅
Plush like a hotel pillow
Supportive latex core
45-day trial period
Moderate height that's ideal for back sleepers
Comes with a pillow cover
Cover and outer pillow are machine washable
What we don’t like ❌
Not adjustable
Too lofty for stomach sleepers
Parachute Down Alternative Pillow (Stomach Sleeper)
Stomach sleepers typically require minimal pillow support as their head and spine are already in relatively good alignment in this position. For most stomach sleepers, a soft pillow with a slight elevation is ideal, making the Parachute Down-Alternative Pillow our top recommendation.
This pillow stood out for its comfort, particularly for my husband, a committed stomach sleeper who often finds other pillows too lofty. The Parachute pillow provides just enough elevation to alleviate any neck strain, and its sateen cotton casing ensures a cool and comfortable sleep, which is especially beneficial for those who tend to run hot.
We've been using four of these pillows for over a year now, and they quickly became our go-to choice before I began testing and evaluating pillows for this guide. Overall, this pillow ticks all the boxes for me: it stays cool, offers incredible softness and comfort, and is hypoallergenic. However, as a back sleeper, I find that I need to stack two or three pillows to achieve the loft required for comfortable sleep.
While the pillow's fill is thin enough to provide some support if you occasionally switch to your side or back during the night, it may not offer enough support for extended periods in these positions. Additionally, it may not provide sufficient lift if you're looking to prop yourself up for activities like reading or watching TV in bed. Nonetheless, it remains an excellent choice for stomach sleepers who have struggled with pillows that are too lofty.
What we like ✅
Soft and pillowy
Made from hypoallergenic down alternative
Folds easily for added support when lying on your side or back
Stays cool
60-day return window
What we don’t like ❌
Needs to be fluffed regularly to retain its shape
Poor support for sleepers who spend the majority of the night on their back or side
Not the best choice for guest bedrooms
Fill cannot be adjusted
Commenti