In the quest for healthier cooking options, the search for PFAS-free pans has become a common trend that is only rapidly growing. As concerns about the potential health risks associated with traditional non-stick coatings grow, consumers are turning towards alternatives that offer both safety and performance. In this review, we'll explore the top contenders in the market, assessing their functionality, durability, and most importantly, their ability to deliver a non-toxic cooking experience without compromising on quality. Whether you're a seasoned chef or a novice in the kitchen, finding the best PFAS-free pan is essential for creating delicious meals while prioritizing your well-being.
Lodge Cast Iron Skillet
Lodge's classic cast iron skillet has consistently topped our list of recommended kitchenware, and for good reason. While it may be slightly heavier than some alternatives, its performance rivals that of any other skillet we've tested, all at an unbeatable price point. Manufactured in the USA by a reputable company with a long-standing history, it's a trusted choice for many households. The 10.25-inch size is versatile and suits most needs, though the larger 12-inch skillet is ideal for larger families. Overall, it's hard to find a compelling reason for most individuals (particularly those in the United States) to consider other options.
Pros: ✅
Lodge skillets have been a longstanding favorite in both the Serious Eats test kitchen and many households for their affordability and quality. With a track record of producing cast iron cookware longer than any other company in the United States, Lodge offers assurance in its craftsmanship. Unlike many similarly priced brands, Lodge continues to manufacture their plain cast iron cookware domestically, adding to its appeal.
Though slightly heavier than the average skillet in this review at approximately 5.5 pounds, the Lodge skillet boasts a comfortable handle suitable for bare-handed use or with a towel or oven mitt. While it may lack the lighter weight and smoother finish of vintage pieces and pricier contemporary brands, its performance remains uncompromised.
Cons ❌
The pour spouts on Lodge skillets are small and shallow, leading to more frequent dribbles and spills in testing. However, considering the affordable price and overall quality, this minor inconvenience may not deter potential buyers.
Lodge Blacklock Triple-Seasoned Cast Iron Pan 10 1/4” Diameter
Lodge's latest addition to its cast iron cookware lineup, the Blacklock series, appears to target the growing trend toward vintage-style cast iron. In a market saturated with startups aiming to revive old cast iron standards with lighter weights and smoother surfaces, Lodge's Blacklock stands out with its notably reduced weight.
Although the Blacklock line may not boast a smoother surface compared to other Lodge cast iron products, its significantly lighter weight is a standout feature. Our testing revealed little to no performance difference between the Blacklock skillet and its heavier counterparts. If you're willing to invest a bit more, you'll likely appreciate the added convenience of maneuvering this skillet around your kitchen with ease.
Pros ✅
Lodge's Blacklock line aims to cater to those seeking cast iron cookware with heritage specifications, including lighter weight and a smoother finish. In a market increasingly focused on reviving old quality standards, Lodge's introduction of the Blacklock series ensures it remains competitive against newer entrants. These skillets excel in their lighter weight, with the 10.25-inch option weighing just 4 pounds 2 ounces, significantly lighter than Lodge's standard offerings. Despite the reduction in weight, our tests found no compromise in performance. The skillet's design exudes a charming vintage aesthetic, particularly in the stylish curves of the stay-cool handle.
Cons ❌
Similar to other Lodge skillets, the Blacklock series features small, shallow pour spouts, which may lead to occasional dribbling or spills.
Le Creuset Signature Enameled Cast Iron Skillet
For those who would rather not season cast iron but still want all of that heat retention, look to enameled cast iron. We separately tested eight enameled cast iron skillets and included one of our favourites, from Le Creuset, here. It heated and seared beautifully and had flared sides, two pour spouts, and a wide, looped helper handle.
Pros ✅
This enameled cast iron skillet impressed us with its exceptional searing performance and overall usability. Featuring a comfortable rounded handle and a looped helper handle, it facilitated effortless lifting and maneuvering during cooking. The inclusion of flared sides and two pour spouts further enhanced its functionality, aiding in tasks such as flipping food and pouring out sauces and oil. While it may come with a higher price tag, we believe that investing in heritage enamel cast iron is justified due to its superior quality control and other notable attributes.
Cons ❌
One drawback we observed was that this pan tended to heat up more slowly compared to others in its class, requiring a bit more patience. Additionally, it's worth noting that this skillet represents an investment, which may not be suitable for every budget.
Le Creuset Toughened Nonstick PRO Fry Pan
For those seeking a nonstick frying pan that combines durability, performance, and aesthetic appeal, the Le Creuset Toughened Nonstick PRO Fry Pan is a standout option. In our extensive testing of nonstick cookware, this model impressed us with its exceptional cooking performance and thoughtful design features. Crafted with Le Creuset's renowned attention to detail, this fry pan delivers professional-level results in the kitchen.
Pros ✅
The Le Creuset Toughened Nonstick PRO Fry Pan excels in its cooking performance, providing even heat distribution and excellent food release. Its durable nonstick coating ensures easy cooking and effortless cleanup, making it ideal for a wide range of recipes, from delicate omelets to hearty stir-fries. The ergonomically designed handle remains cool to the touch, offering a comfortable and secure grip during cooking. Additionally, the large cooking surface and high sides provide ample space for cooking multiple ingredients at once, while the flared rim facilitates drip-free pouring.
Cons ❌
One drawback we observed is that the pan's nonstick coating may show signs of wear over time with frequent use, though proper care and maintenance can help prolong its lifespan. Additionally, the Le Creuset Toughened Nonstick PRO Fry Pan is priced at a premium compared to other nonstick options on the market. However, we believe its superior performance, durability, and timeless design make it a worthwhile investment for serious home cooks and culinary enthusiasts looking for long-lasting quality.
GreenPan Valencia Skillet
For those seeking a PFAS free, healthy and eco-friendly alternative to traditional nonstick cookware, the GreenPan Valencia Pro Hard Anodized Ceramic Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet offers an impressive combination of performance and sustainability.
In our comprehensive testing of ceramic nonstick PFAS free pans, this model stood out for its exceptional cooking performance and durable construction. Crafted with premium materials and innovative technology, it provides a versatile and reliable option for home cooks. It also extremely well priced hoovering between $50 and $80 depending on what size pan you choose.
Pros ✅
The GreenPan Valencia Pro Frying Pan Skillet impressed us with its superior cooking performance and durable construction. Its hard anodized aluminum body ensures even heat distribution, while the Thermolon ceramic nonstick coating offers effortless food release and easy cleanup. The pan's ergonomic stainless steel handle remains cool to the touch during cooking, providing a comfortable and secure grip. Additionally, the scratch-resistant exterior and reinforced edges enhance durability, making it suitable for everyday use. Moreover, GreenPan's commitment to sustainability is evident in their use of recycled materials and PFOA-free manufacturing process, making it a healthier choice for both you and the environment.
Cons ❌
One drawback we noticed is that the nonstick coating may wear off over time with frequent use, though proper care and maintenance can help prolong its lifespan. Additionally, some users may find the pan's handle slightly heavy compared to other models, though this is a minor issue considering its overall performance and durability. While the GreenPan Valencia Pro Frying Pan Skillet is priced at a premium compared to other ceramic nonstick options on the market, we believe its exceptional quality and eco-friendly features justify the investment for health-conscious consumers and environmentally conscious home cooks alike.
How We Tested
Durability: The durability of the pan's construction materials, such as hard anodized aluminum and scratch-resistant exterior, was assessed to determine its resistance to warping, scratching, and general wear and tear over time.
Cooking Performance: The pan's ability to distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface and facilitate easy food release without sticking was evaluated through various cooking tests, including searing, frying, and sautéing.
Nonstick Coating Quality: The quality and longevity of the ceramic nonstick coating, specifically how well it maintains its nonstick properties over time and with repeated use, were examined to assess its durability and effectiveness.
Ease of Use and Cleanup: The ergonomic design of the pan's handle, its comfort, and ability to stay cool during cooking, as well as how easy it is to clean the pan after use, were considered important factors in its usability and practicality in the kitchen.
Sustainability: GreenPan's commitment to sustainability, including the use of recycled materials and a PFOA-free manufacturing process, was taken into account to evaluate its eco-friendliness and appeal to environmentally conscious consumers.
Price Point: The price of the GreenPan Valencia Pro Frying Pan Skillet was compared to other ceramic nonstick pans on the market to assess its value proposition and determine whether its premium price was justified by its features and performance.
Comments