Buffy Cloud Comforter - Best Overall
Buffy's comforter claims the top spot on our list due to its exceptional softness and innovative design, which effectively prevents clumping, shedding, and the formation of cold spots. Unlike traditional comforters, it utilizes a unique construction with a down-alternative fill consisting of a web of fibers rather than individual clusters. Additionally, its cover features wavy stitching instead of squares, preventing compression of the layers.
In terms of sustainability, this comforter stands out among its counterparts. Its polyester fill is crafted from recycled plastic bottles, and it boasts a Global Recycling Standard (GRS) certification to validate its eco-friendly credentials. Furthermore, the outer cover is made of Tencel lyocell, a responsibly sourced material known for its smoothness, lightweight feel, and temperature-regulating properties.
Endorsed by textile experts, the Buffy comforter has found a place in their own homes, impressing testers with its unparalleled comfort. Described as akin to sleeping on a cloud, users laud its plushness and lack of crinkly noises, a common issue with many comforters. Moreover, feedback indicates that it maintains a comfortable temperature year-round, with one user noting its substantial feel without causing overheating. It's worth noting, however, that this comforter is available in only one warmth level.
Fill: Polyester | Outer cover: Tencel lyocell | Construction: Stitched-through | Sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen and King/California King
Pros
Light and fluffy fill
Soft, quiet outer cover
GH textile experts use it in their own homes
Cons
Only one warmth level available
Linenspa All-Season Down Alternative Comforter - Best Value
This comforter has gained immense popularity on Amazon, boasting an impressive 125,000 reviews and maintaining an average rating of 4.5 stars. Remarkably, despite its significantly lower price compared to others on the market, it's highly regarded by users for its lightweight and fluffy qualities. Additionally, it offers the convenience of being machine washable, although it's advisable to use a large-capacity machine for optimal care.
Available in a single all-season warmth level, this comforter is crafted from polyester, both for its fill and outer cover. While this material may not be the most luxurious choice, it may not be suitable for those prone to overheating during sleep. Furthermore, its quilted construction lacks the secure separation provided by baffle boxes. However, considering its stellar feedback, range of options (including six colors and eight sizes), and unbeatable price point, it presents a compelling option for budget-conscious shoppers in search of a reliable comforter.
Fill: Polyester | Outer cover: Polyester | Construction: Box stitch | Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Oversized Queen and Oversized King
Pros
Affordable
Top-rated on Amazon
Comes in multiple colours and designs
Cons
Polyester cover isn't ideal for hot sleepers
Rest Evercool Cooling Comforter - Best Cooling
If you're mindful of the sourcing of your down but aren't inclined to invest in our higher-priced selections, the Target Casaluna Premium Down Comforter All Season offers an affordable alternative without compromising on ethical standards.
This budget-friendly comforter features ethical down feathers and holds the RDS certification for ethical sourcing. Priced at less than half of the Brooklinen comforter and approximately a third of the Feathered Friends comforter, it also carries the Oeko-Tex certification. Notably, among our selections, only the Casaluna and Feathered Friends comforters possess both certifications. Being a part of Target's "owned brands," the Casaluna comforter benefits from a one-year return policy, exceeding the company's standard 90-day policy.
Despite its lower cost, the Casaluna comforter provides comfort and warmth. While it may not match the fluffiness of the Brooklinen or Feathered Friends comforters, nor offer the same smooth fabric, it delivers satisfactory comfort, warmth, and durability for its price point. Filled with 600-fill-power duck down, it feels slightly heavier but maintains effective warmth without causing discomfort. Available in three weight options—Lightweight, All Season, and Heavyweight—the All Season variant is recommended for most climates and seasons.
Crafted with a sturdy cotton sateen outer shell, the Casaluna comforter exhibits solid construction and minimal shedding during shake tests, distinguishing it from other budget options. Its sewn-through construction prevents excessive shifting or clumping of down during laundering, making it easier to wash at home and a preferable choice for those who prefer frequent washing. However, it's worth noting that some feather shedding may occur after prolonged use, typically after about a year.
Fill: Sorona and Tencel | Outer cover: Nylon/spandex | Construction: Stitched through | Sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/California King
Pros
Cold-to-the-touch and moisture-wicking fabric
Allows hot sleepers to use a cover
Lightweight
Cons
Use without a duvet cover; less aesthetic for those who prioritize appearance
PeachSkinSheets Oversized Comforter Set - Best Oversized
Designed with restless sleepers and couples in mind, this oversized comforter offers generous coverage, effortlessly draping over the sides of your bed to accommodate various sleeping habits and blanket tussles. Crafted from plush polyester for both its fill and cover, it provides a cozy embrace that may prove too warm for individuals prone to overheating but should suit the preferences of most sleepers. With a selection of 32 colors available, this comforter offers versatility, allowing you to forgo a duvet cover if desired. Additionally, the inclusion of matching shams completes the ensemble, providing a cohesive look for your bedding setup.
During testing, our evaluators were astounded by the comfort and practicality of this comforter. One remarked on the luxurious feel of the outer fabric, likening it to being enveloped in a cloud of softness and warmth. Another tester declared it as the best comforter they've ever experienced, emphasizing its superior quality and comfort. A third tester appreciated its ability to stay in place on the bed, stating, "It gave me lots of space to roll around with it." Furthermore, users with taller beds noted that it draped more effectively than standard comforters, further enhancing its appeal and functionality.
Fill: Polyester | Outer cover: Polyester | Construction: Box stitch | Sizes: Super Twin/Twin XL, Super Full, Super Queen, Super King/California King
Pros
Soft and cozy materials
More coverage on beds than other comforters
Available in 32 colours with matching shams included
Cons
Polyester outer fabric may feel too warm for some
How We Tested
Material Quality: Evaluating the materials used in the comforters, including the fill, cover fabric, and stitching, to assess their durability, softness, and overall comfort.
Warmth and Breathability: Assessing the comforter's ability to provide warmth without causing overheating, as well as its breathability to ensure a comfortable sleep environment.
Size and Coverage: Considering the size of the comforter and how well it covers the bed, particularly for larger or taller mattresses, to ensure adequate coverage and comfort.
Ethical Sourcing: Reviewing the sourcing of materials, such as down feathers, to ensure ethical and sustainable practices are followed, which may include certifications like Responsible Down Standard (RDS).
Ease of Care: Examining how easy the comforter is to clean and maintain, including whether it's machine washable and if it retains its quality after washing.
Design and Aesthetics: Considering the design elements of the comforter, such as color options, patterns, and overall aesthetic appeal, to suit different bedroom styles and preferences.
User Feedback and Reviews: Taking into account feedback and reviews from actual users to gauge real-world experiences with the comforter, including factors like comfort, durability, and value for money.
Price and Value: Assessing the comforter's price relative to its quality, features, and performance to determine its overall value for consumers.
Comments